Is Creatine Safe For Athletes? Myths And Facts

Known for its role in enhancing athletic performance, creatine is a natural substance that boosts the production of ATP. What makes it a cornerstone in the world of sports supplements? This magic substance has the ability to boost muscle mass and strength, improve recovery, and enhance overall performance. However, this popularity has also come hand in hand with myths and misconceptions about creatine usage that persist to this day. But is creatine really safe for athletes? To understand its true impact, it is crucial for athletes and bodybuilders to bridge the gap between assumptions and the truth about creatine supplementation

What is Creatine?

Creatine plays a key role in energy production, especially in muscle cells. It is synthesised in the liver, kidneys, and pancreas from three key amino acids: arginine, glycine, and methionine. After that, it is transported through the blood to the muscle cells and other areas of high energy demand. Creatine is stored as phosphocreatine in our skeletal muscles. Phosphocreatine helps refuel ATP (adenosine triphosphate) by donating its phosphate group. This ATP boost improves muscle endurance, performance and post-workout recovery, making it a popular supplement among athletes and fitness enthusiasts

How Does Creatine Benefit Athletic Performance?

Creatine enhances ATP regeneration—we know that! But what makes creatine improve athletic performance? Here is a breakdown:

1. It enhances strength and power. Creatine releases a phosphate group, replenishing ATP and allowing you to perform more powerful muscle contractions. This allows you to lift heavier weights, perform more repetitions or push your limits during your workout or training session.
2. It builds endurance. By helping maintain ATP levels, creatine delays muscle fatigue during intense workout sessions. This leads to longer endurance during high-intensity workouts, resulting in better results.
3. It helps in muscle recovery. Creatine helps reduce muscle damage and inflammation after high-intensity training. If your muscles recover quickly, you are ready for the next training session. This means you can train more frequently with less muscle soreness.
4. It helps enhance focus and cognitive performance. Creatine also plays a crucial role in improving cognitive function and mental focus. Studies suggest that creatine supplementation can help reduce cognitive stress and also might alleviate sleep deprivation.

Some of the Common Myths Around Creatine: Explained

Creatine supplementation comes with a range of opinions and myths about its usage. However, it generally is great if used in conjunction with a healthy diet, proper hydration, and regular exercise. It is not a magic bullet, but if taken under the supervision of your healthcare provider, it can help power your training sessions. Let’s highlight those myths around creatine and discover the benefits of creatine for athletes:

1. MYTH: Creatine supplementation leads to kidney damage.

REALITY: If creatine is used within the recommended dosage limits, it is completely safe for kidney function. This concern is raised because of the by-product of creatine breakdown – creatinine. If the muscles of the body do not utilise creatine effectively, the excess of it gets converted to creatinine. This rise in creatinine levels is mistaken as an indicator of kidney stress. However, this condition is harmless in people with healthy kidneys. If you have a pre-existing kidney condition, creatine supplements for athletes must be done under expert supervision.
Also, if you have an existing kidney problem, creatine is not advisable, as your kidneys might have a hard time filtering creatinine.

2. MYTH: Creatine Supplementation Leads to Hair Loss

REALITY: An experiment of creatine supplements in 2009 on a group of rugby players resulted in increased levels of DHT (dihydrotestosterone) by 56%. Since increased levels of DTH are linked to hair loss conditions in individuals, this myth came into existence. However, even after multiple experiments were carried out, there were no results that proved this true. Thus, creatine has no contribution to hair loss.

3. MYTH: Creatine Supplementation Causes Excessive Water Retention

REALITY: During the loading phase, when creatine dosages are higher, around 20 grams per day for a week, creatine supplementation might cause temporary water retention. This happens because creatine draws water into the muscle cells. However, if creatine is taken in lower dosages during the maintenance phase, around 3-5 grams per day, the risk of water retention is lower. Choosing a micronised creatine monohydrate is a good option. Try to avoid unnecessarily high doses or loading phases to avoid such issues while still benefiting from creatine’s performance-enhancing effects.

4. MYTH: Creatine Supplementation Leads to Stomach Upset.

REALITY: If you have just started with creatine supplementation, you might face mild, temporary symptoms like bloating, diarrhoea, gas, and abdominal muscle cramps. Bloating might happen due to creatine’s water retention property. However, the real reason may be the high dosage taken during the loading phase. You can always minimise or control the risk of stomach upset by reducing your dosage.

5. MYTH: Creatine Supplementation Increases Body Fat.

REALITY: Creatine pulls water into the muscles, thus causing puffiness around the cells. This temporary water retention is commonly associated with weight gain. However, creatine increases lean body mass without affecting fat mass.

6. MYTH: Can creatine be taken without regular exercise?

REALITY: Not really. Creatine supplementation surely enhances strength and endurance, but it cannot replace the need for exercise in building that strength. Creatine helps your muscles produce more energy during short or intense bursts of activity, like weightlifting and sprinting, and faster recovery. This can lead to improved training results and muscle growth over time. Creatine doesn’t magically build muscle without the proper stimulation from exercise.

7. MYTH: ‘Loading Phase’ is mandatory in creatine supplementation.

REALITY: The concept of the loading phase was to provide immediate strength and performance gains to people doing intense training. In some people, it might go well, but in other cases, it causes mild diarrhoea or stomach upset. But it is not necessary for everyone. It is proven that smaller regular doses of 3-5 g can also help make the most of creatine supplementation, but this approach may require additional time when compared with the loading phase.

There may be more myths around creatine supplementation for athletes, but we recommend understanding the science behind its working before forming an opinion about it. Choose the best quality creatine monohydrate supplement that boosts muscle energy by increasing creatine phosphate levels, leading to more ATP production.

Benefits of Creatine for Muscle Gains and Performance

With all the confusion surrounding creatine, many people hesitate to take the supplement. But let us throw some light on the benefits of creatine for muscle gain and performance improvement:

1. High-intensity training, along with appropriate supplementation, can lead to faster gains in lean muscle mass.
2. With its quick ATP generation, creatine helps improve strength, power output and ability to finish more repetitions during intense training.
3. Creatine may help the muscles recover more quickly after intense exercise, potentially reducing muscle damage and soreness.
4. Due to its ability to draw water into the muscle cells, creatine leads to temporary water weight gain, making muscles appear fuller.

Is Creatine Safe For Athletes?

Creatine is a completely safe supplement for athletes. It has mild, temporary side effects like bloating or diarrhoea in the loading phase, but once your body adapts to its smaller dose, it is harmless. It not only improves strength and enhances performance but also helps you push your limits.

What Is the Best Way to Take Creatine for Maximum Results?

There is no standard time at which creatine should be taken. However, for the best results, creatine should not be taken on an empty stomach. Studies suggest taking up to 20 g of creatine monohydrate daily for 5 to 7 days is the most effective way to increase your muscle creatine levels. This phase is called the loading phase, followed by the maintenance phase, where you must take 2-3 g of creatine monohydrate every day.

Should Young Athletes Use a Creatine Supplement?

Although creatine supplementation purely enhances performance in young athletes, the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American College of Sports Medicine do not recommend it for athletes under 18 due to a lack of proper research and potential side effects.

Bottom Line

Lastly, creatine is not a steroid. It does not cause dehydration, kidney damage, or fat gain when used as guided by experts. Creatine primarily enhances performance by increasing energy production in muscles, leading to improved strength and muscle mass. Athletes and powerlifters should be well-versed before adding creatine to their fitness regimen, staying confident in its proven benefits and safety without falling for common myths.

Frequently Asked Questions